Hypnosis for Alcohol Treatment Debated
Hypnosis for Alcohol Treatment Debated
April 14, 2004 News Summary
Hypnosis for treating alcohol addiction, promoted by a treatment facility in Virginia, is being questioned by some medical experts, the Washington Post reported April 13.
At Phoenix Method One in Virginia, client evaluations are used to bolster the case for hypnosis: the center claims a 90-percent success rate for clients reducing or stopping their alcohol use.
“We know we have a very high success rate,” said Marika Runnells, co-founder and director of therapy at Phoenix Method One. “Our comprehensive feedback process proves it.”
But Robert Nebiker, director of the Virginia Department of Health Professions, said use of hypnosis is only approved for treating smoking. Using hypnosis for other medical conditions, such as alcohol addiction, may be in violation of state law governing the practice of medicine, he said.
“One of the things we would look at is whether people are being harmed or defrauded,” Nebiker said. “We would try to determine whether there was any scientific basis for this treatment or whether it was just someone taking your money. We would also look at the training of the people doing it and what their claims are. If you claim, ‘Come and be hypnotized by me and in six easy sessions you won’t be alcoholic,’ that would be suspect.’”
The success claims made of the Phoenix Method One have also come in for scrutiny. “If they’re getting 90 percent, they should bottle it,” said David Spiegel, a professor of psychiatry at the Stanford University School of Medicine and one of the nation’s highly regarded experts in the clinical uses of hypnosis. “Nobody gets 90 percent doing anything. I don’t care what it is.”
Stephen Barrett, a retired psychiatrist who heads Quackwatch, a nonprofit medical watchdog group, said controlled research is needed to determine whether hypnosis is an effective treatment for alcohol addiction.
“The fact that people stopped smoking or drinking after they had hypnosis doesn’t mean it was due to the treatment itself,” Barrett said. “We know that a certain number of people who set out to stop will do so on their own regardless of the method they employ.”
COMMENTS ON THIS ARTICLE:
Incoming search terms for the article:
Similar articles
- Stop Alcohol Addiction with Deep Trance Hypnosis
“First you take a drink, then the drink takes a drink, then the drink takes you.” – Francis Scott Key Fitzgerald Some people drink in order to fit better with the crowd, some people drink to forget their problems. It is a way of numbing one’s senses when one wants to run away, but ... - Hypnosis Alcohol Treatment
Hypnosis Alcohol Treatment! Has alcohol become a problem for you? Are you ready for change? Whether you would like to stop drinking alcohol completely or just reduce the amount of alcohol you drink, Beverly Hills Hypnosis Alcohol Treatment CD and MP3 can help! Beverly Hills Hypnosis Alcohol Treatment CDs and MP3s use a ... - Stop Drinking Alcohol: Stop Drinking by Hypnosis
Hypnotherapy and Self-Hypnosis to Stop Drinking Alcohol Are these methods to stop drinking alcohol and beating alcoholism really effective in terms of overcoming the bad habit of abusing alcohol? What are the principles behind these alcoholism treatments and how effective are they when it comes to stopping drinking? What is hypnosis and how ... - Alcohol Addiction Abuse
Alcoholism, also known as alcohol dependence, is a disabling addictive disorder. It is characterized by compulsive and uncontrolled consumption of alcohol despite its negative effects on the drinker’s health, relationships, and social standing. Like other drug addictions, alcoholism is medically defined as a treatable disease. The term “alcoholism” is a widely used term first coined ... - Wellness and Health Hypnosis Dallas Fort Worth
The services I render are held out to the public as non-therapeutic Hypnotism, defined as the use of Hypnosis to bring about positive thinking and the capacity for self-Hypnosis. I do not represent my services as any form of medical, behavioral or mental health care, and despite research to the contrary, by law I ...
Twitter